This Exam P sample reference tests Conditional Probability. The non-student-default group contributes 0.196 to the joint car-default probability. Solving the reverse conditional relation gives a 0.43556 car-default probability among student-loan defaulters, choice C.
These notes identify the calculation error associated with each wrong letter when that error is reproducible.
AThe value 0.33 is the marginal car-default probability 0.32667 rounded. The observation specifies a student-loan default, so the joint probability must be divided by 0.30.
BThe value 0.40 reverses the conditioning and reports P(S|C), which is supplied. The requested direction is P(C|S).
DThe value 0.65 results from dividing the non-student-default joint contribution by the student-default share: 0.196/0.30 = 0.65333. Those two quantities belong to different conditioning groups.
EThe value 0.72 is 1-0.28, the probability of no car default among borrowers without a student-loan default. It uses the wrong conditioning group and event.
Original practice · fully worked
Original variant: alteration risk after a clean screen
A document archive contains 12% altered files. A screening rule flags 85% of altered files and incorrectly flags 6% of unaltered files. One file is selected at random and receives no flag. Determine the conditional probability that this file is altered.
A 0.01800
B 0.02130
C 0.06000
D 0.15000
E 0.97870
Variant answer in brief
An altered-and-unflagged file has probability 0.018, while the total no-flag probability is 0.8452. Their ratio is 0.02130, choice B.
Setup
Setup
Convert the two flag rates to no-flag rates for altered and unaltered files.
Pr(N∣A)=1−0.85=0.15
Pr(N∣Ac)=1−0.06=0.94
Model
Model
Compute the two mutually exclusive contributions to receiving no flag.
Pr(A∩N)=(0.12)(0.15)=0.018
Pr(Ac∩N)=(0.88)(0.94)=0.8272
Compute
Compute
Normalize the altered contribution within all unflagged files.
Pr(N)=0.018+0.8272=0.8452
Pr(A∣N)=0.84520.018=0.0212967
Answer
Answer
The posterior alteration probability is about 2.13%.
The 3108-page Probability Proof Manual reorganizes 718 verified Exam P solutions by syllabus skill and adds formula proofs, error patterns, and original worked practice.