This Exam P sample reference tests Bayes' Theorem. A positive indication has defective-board mass 0.10(0.80)=0.08 and nondefective-board mass 0.90(0.60)=0.54. Bayes' formula gives 0.08/0.62=4/31, so choice D is correct.
These notes identify the calculation error associated with each wrong letter when that error is reproducible.
AThis reports the joint probability Pr(D and T)=(0.10)(0.80)=0.08=2/25 without dividing by the total positive-test probability.
BThis reports the prior defective probability 0.10 and ignores the information supplied by the observed test indication.
CThis uses 0.60 as the entire false-positive contribution instead of multiplying by the 0.90 nondefective prior, giving 0.08/(0.08+0.60)=2/17.
EThis treats the 0.40 specificity as the false-positive rate, giving 0.08/[0.08+(0.40)(0.90)]=2/11.
Original practice · fully worked
Original variant: two independent anomaly flags
One percent of data packets entering a network are corrupted. Two monitoring rules evaluate each packet. Conditional on whether a packet is corrupted, the rules act independently. Each rule flags a corrupted packet with probability 0.90 and flags an intact packet with probability 0.05. A packet triggers both rules. Calculate the probability that it is corrupted.
A 0.0081
B 0.1406
C 0.1538
D 0.7660
E 0.9900
Variant answer in brief
Conditional independence makes the two-flag likelihoods 0.90² for corrupted packets and 0.05² for intact packets. Bayes' formula gives 0.0081/(0.0081+0.002475)=0.76596, so choice D is correct.
Setup
Setup
Let C denote corruption and F the event that both rules flag the packet.
Pr(C)=0.01,Pr(Cc)=0.99
Model
Model
Conditional independence lets each two-rule likelihood be written as a product.
Pr(F∣C)=0.902=0.81
Pr(F∣Cc)=0.052=0.0025
Compute
Compute
Weight both likelihoods by their prior probabilities and normalize the corrupted-packet mass.
Pr(C∩F)=0.01(0.81)=0.0081
Pr(Cc∩F)=0.99(0.0025)=0.002475
Pr(C∣F)=0.0081+0.0024750.0081=0.7659574468
Answer
Answer
A packet triggering both rules is corrupted with probability about 0.7660.
The 3108-page Probability Proof Manual reorganizes 718 verified Exam P solutions by syllabus skill and adds formula proofs, error patterns, and original worked practice.