Independent solution

How to solve this Interest Rate Valuation question

Setup

Setup

Compare purchasing power using accumulation factors rather than subtracting rates.

1+inom=(1+ireal)(1+r)1+i_{\mathrm{nom}}=(1+i_{\mathrm{real}})(1+r)

Model

Model

Remove the 5% price-level growth from the 9% nominal investment growth.

1+ireal=1.091.051+i_{\mathrm{real}}=\frac{1.09}{1.05}

Compute

Compute

The factor ratio gives real rate 0.038095.

ireal=0.038095i_{\mathrm{real}}=0.038095

Answer

Answer

The real annual effective return is about 3.8%, corresponding to choice B.

ireal3.8%(B)\boxed{i_{\mathrm{real}}\approx3.8\%\quad\text{(B)}}