Independent solution

How to solve this Cash-Flow and Risk Matching question

Setup

Setup

Compare how tightly each asset-liability technique constrains the available cash-flow pattern.

CFA,t=CFL,tt exact matchCF_{A,t}=CF_{L,t}\quad\forall t\ \Longrightarrow\text{exact match}

Model

Model

Exact matching requires equality at every liability date, while Redington conditions constrain present value, duration, and convexity instead.

PVA=PVL,DA=DL,CA>CL RedingtonPV_A=PV_L,\quad D_A=D_L,\quad C_A>C_L\ \Longrightarrow\text{Redington}

Compute

Compute

The date-by-date requirement is more restrictive, so immunization generally leaves the manager more investment choices.

{exact matches}{duration-based candidates}\{\text{exact matches}\}\subset\{\text{duration-based candidates}\}

Answer

Answer

That is precisely the claim in choice B.

statement B(B)\boxed{\text{statement B}\quad\text{(B)}}