Independent solution

How to solve this Yield Uniqueness and Bounds question

Setup

Setup

Order the project cash flows by time. Their signs move from negative outlays to positive receipts exactly once.

(,,+,+)(-,-,+,+)

Model

Model

A single sign change makes the positive yield root unique. Evaluate the 50% benchmark by asking when the final receipt would make net present value zero.

30401.5+601.52+901.5n=0-30-\frac{40}{1.5}+\frac{60}{1.5^2}+\frac{90}{1.5^n}=0

Compute

Compute

The benchmark equation reduces to 1.5 to the n equals 3, so n would be 2.71. The actual final receipt occurs later than year 3 and is worth less at 50%.

n=ln3ln1.5=2.7095<3n=\frac{\ln3}{\ln1.5}=2.7095<3

Answer

Answer

A lower discount rate is needed to restore zero NPV; the unique yield is below 50%, choice B.

unique yield below 50%(B)\boxed{\text{unique yield below }50\%\quad\text{(B)}}